The Diehard Cubs’ Fan Suggestion Box: Finding A Starting Pitcher

The Cubs plan to add a pitcher to the starting rotation.  Let’s examine the current pool of free agents and try to find the best fit. 

First, I will list some of the best options, then we’ll go from there and decide who would fit in well with the Cubs.

Erik Bedard is a left-hander with solid numbers.  A career 3.71 ERA and a 51-41 record.  He has one of the best curve balls in the majors.

thumbnailCAWB8W30.jpgJeff Francis, another southpaw, has a career 55-50 record and a 4.77 ERA.

thumbnailCABDVWYO.jpgFreddy Garcia is a right-handed veteran who knows how to win.  A career 133-87 record and a 4.13 ERA.  He has 1,390 career strikeouts.

The Cubs have reported interest in Jon Garland, a former Whitesox right-hander.  He has a 131-114 record in 11 seasons.  He has 1096 career K’s with an ERA of 4.32.

Cliff Lee is probably not an option.  That’s all I will say, other than yes, I want him on the Cubs too.

Aaron Harang has an 81-87 record and a 4.33 ERA.

Vincente Padilla has a 104-90 record and a 4.31 ERA.  He has thrown over a thousand strike outs.

Brad Penny is available.  He boasts a 108-88 record with a 4.11 ERA.  He has 1,176 K’s in 11 seasons.  Penny was injured most of last year.

Andy Pettite is 39, but has proven that he can still pitch.  A post-season veteran who knows how to win.  In 16 seasons, Pettite has a 240-138 career record, 3.88 ERA, and 2251 K’s.

Brandon Webb has had his set-backs but will be on the Free Agent market.  He is 87-62, has a 3.27 ERA, and over a thousand strikeouts in 7 seasons.

Jake Westbrook has a career 73-75 record, a 4.29 ERA in 10 seasons.

thumbnailCAV5RYUN.jpgWith the struggles that Dontrelle Willis has had with Detroit, the Cubs may find a bargain, provided he can turn his career around.  The D-Train is a lefty with a 71-63 record and a 4.12 ERA.  He has declined over the past few seasons and has some serious question marks.  He was drafted by the Cubs so maybe the Cubs could resurrect his career.

The San Diego Padres parted company with Chris Young.  Although he is bouncing back from surgery last year, Young remains a solid pitcher, but has something to prove, mainly that he is healthy.  He has a 3.80 ERA in his career, with a 48-34 win-loss record in 7 seasons.

Jeremy Bonderman is last on the list.  He has a 67-77 record and a 4.89 ERA in 8 seasons.

That is the list of possibilities that the Cubs may explore to complete the starting rotation.  If a pitcher wasn’t listed, then I felt that they weren’t a good fit.  I have not concluded who I would want, but a few of my favorites are the ones listed.  Hopefully the Cubs will choose wisely amongst them. 

Among trade possibilities, the Cubs may pursue Zack Greinke.  The Kansas City Royals are willing to make a trade.  K.C. has reported that they will accept trade offers if the other team is willing to part with 2 Major League ready starting pitchers. 
thumbnailCAF09JUT.jpgThe Cubs have quite a few pitchers that the Royals may be interested in.  We’ll see if Jim Hendry makes a pitch for him in the offseason.  He is a solid starter, but is still owed 27 million over the next few years, so it isn’t clear if the Cubs are willing to take on more salary.  We’ll have to wait and see.

Those are my suggestions.  A left-handed starter would be a good choice to replace the absence of Ted Lilly, but a solid right-hander would also work.  Let’s go out and get some solid pitching.  Go Cubs!

 Please add to the SUGGESTION BOX.  Feel free to leave a comment.  Who do you think would be the best fit?



One comment

  1. raysrenegade

    Brad Penny might need a nice contract since he just proposed to his “Dancing With The Stars” girlfriend Karina Smirnoff a few days ago.
    Plus I am hearing a few chirps that the Cubs like Carlos Pena as a defensive up-grade at First Base for 2011.
    There will be plenty of dangling starters come Monday morning. I hope the Cubs do some due dilligence this Hot Stove season and look behind the mirror a few times to get the right additon for the club.

    Rays Renegade

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s